At some point in the last decade, the internet decided that every opinion has to be absolute.
You can’t think a movie was okay. It’s either a masterpiece or garbage. You can’t partially agree with someone. You either support them completely or you’re enabling the opposition. You can’t say “this is complicated” without being accused of fence-sitting, both-sidesing, or being part of the problem.
Nuance didn’t die of natural causes. It got murdered by engagement metrics.
The Algorithm Reward System
Here’s why the internet sounds the way it does. Every major platform — Twitter, TikTok, Instagram, YouTube — rewards content that generates strong reactions. Comments, shares, quote tweets, rage-clicks. The algorithm doesn’t care if the reaction is positive or negative. It just wants engagement.
And what generates the most engagement? Extreme positions. Bold claims. Outrage. “This person is WRONG and here’s why.” Not measured analysis. Not “well, there are several factors to consider.” Nobody shares that.
So creators, journalists, commentators, and regular people all learned the same lesson: if you want attention, take the strongest possible position. Dial it to eleven. Complexity is the enemy of virality.
The result is an information environment where every issue is presented as a binary. You’re with us or against us. On every single topic, from politics to pizza toppings.
The Pile-On Economy
Cancel culture gets talked about constantly, but the deeper problem is the pile-on economy. Someone says something questionable — not evil, just questionable — and within hours, thousands of people are dunking on them.
Not engaging with the idea. Not asking for clarification. Dunking. Because dunking gets likes. And likes feel good. And the person being dunked on becomes a prop in everyone else’s personal branding exercise.
The pile-on doesn’t distinguish between genuine harm and minor missteps. A poorly worded tweet gets the same treatment as a legitimately harmful action. And once the pile-on starts, trying to add context or defend the person makes you a target too.
So people learn to stay quiet. Or they learn to only express opinions that are pre-approved by their tribe. Either way, the range of acceptable public thought gets narrower every year.
“It’s Complicated” Is Not Cowardice
Somewhere along the way, saying “I don’t have a strong opinion on this” became suspicious. As if having uncertainty means you’re hiding something. As if every person needs a hot take on every topic at all times.
But most important issues are genuinely complicated. The economy is complicated. Immigration is complicated. Technology’s impact on society is complicated. Having the intellectual honesty to say “I see valid points on multiple sides” isn’t weakness. It’s the most accurate position on most topics.
The problem is that accuracy doesn’t perform well online. “It’s complicated” doesn’t fit in a tweet. It doesn’t get retweeted. It doesn’t build a following. So people pick a side — not because they’re convinced, but because the platform demands it.
What We Lost
When nuance disappears from public discourse, a few things happen.
People stop changing their minds. If every position is a tribal identity, changing your view feels like betrayal. You can’t update your thinking without your audience calling you a sellout.
Solutions get harder to find. Real solutions to real problems almost always involve trade-offs and compromise. But if compromise is seen as surrender, nothing gets solved. Everyone just gets louder.
Trust collapses. When every public statement is performatively extreme, nobody believes anyone is being honest. Everything sounds like a take, even when someone is being genuine. We’ve poisoned the well so thoroughly that sincerity itself looks suspicious.
Can We Fix This?
Probably not at the platform level. The engagement model is too profitable. As long as outrage drives clicks, the incentive structure rewards extremism.
But individuals can opt out of the game. You can follow people who think out loud instead of performing certainty. You can resist the urge to dunk and instead ask questions. You can say “I’m not sure” in a room full of people who are very sure.
It won’t go viral. But it might make the internet a little less exhausting.
And honestly, at this point, that would be enough.
Got a take? Disagree? Think we’re being dramatic? Good. That’s the point. Come back tomorrow — we’ve got more to say.